you make no valid arguments, the first one you posted, chuck , i already responded too, he made 3.5 times as many posts as your brother this year
but more importantly than that
"HE COMES TO AND HANGS OUT WITH THE GROUP"
thats more important than posting, and i even said that early on, even if he didn't post much, he could hang out with some people
if he doesn't want to post on the board, doesn't want to hang with anyone, then why would/should he be on the list